Garage ignored unsafe heater ruling
A car repair garage has been given a conditional discharge and ordered to pay £500 towards court costs after ignoring a Health and Safety Executive order to stop using a dangerous gas heater.
Bow Street Garage, in Rugeley, Staffordshire had been warned that its Powrmatic gas heater posed serious safety issues for customers and workers, and residents living in the connected buildings.
The HSA found that deadly carbon monoxide fumes could be released into the workshop through the heater’s exhaust flue which was directed inside the building.
Stafford Magistrates’ Court heard how, on 3 December 2009, an inspector from the HSE issued the company with a Prohibition Notice requiring it to stop using the heater. As well as problems with the flue, the electrical wiring system was unsuitable and the system required servicing by a competent gas engineer.
When the inspector returned to the site a month later, he noticed the workshop was noticeably warmer than outside. As soon as one of the directors of the company, Ian Moore, recognised the inspector, he switched the heater off. Mr Moore claimed it had been on for no more than 45 minutes in order to help dry the workshop floor that had just been mopped after an oil spillage.
Bow Street Garage Ltd pleaded guilty to breaching Section 33(1)(g) of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974. It escaped any further action because it has now ceased trading.
It seems basic common sense to comply with instructions issued by an HSE inspector, however I am frequently amazed by the failure of some businesses to act on the written or verbal instructions received. It is simply not geed business sense and it is not surprising that the company has gone out of business……